I took some frugal steps before the purchase:
1) It fulfills a determined want/need
2) I waited more than a week to inquire about the item
3) I waited another 3 days before deciding to look at it in person
4) I checked the budget
5) I withdrew cash and split it so I knew my offer price and my top price
6) I looked at it in person
So, you ask...what was this?
It was, and is something super cool.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5f53d/5f53d6d59574dd6c097c329ac348b91a1409c6bc" alt="1"
It is an old hotel safe with "safe deposit" type boxes in each little locking cubbie.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1ef37/1ef374c350af5bf4200b78a7073704b5e19d2600" alt=""
The locks all turn, and have keys. It's so fiddly and oak and heavy.
Here's how it fits in with the above frugal steps:
1) It fulfills a determined want/need -- I wanted something cool to put my silverware and other small kitchen things in when I finally get a real house built. I have items to make shelves and a countertop but no drawers or small item mouse proof storage. I was looking for something unique to use for that. This should be it.
2) I waited more than a week to inquire about the item -- I saw it on craigslist and I waited and thought about it before contacting the seller.
3) I waited another 3 days before deciding to look at it in person -- Once I did contact the seller and determined it was still available, I let it go another few days.
4) I checked the budget -- self-explanatory
5) I withdrew cash and split it so I knew my offer price and my top price -- it cost a few hundred bucks. So, I pulled as much as I was willing to spend, put as much as I WANTED to pay into one of those bank envelopes so it looked like I had a hard budget. The rest was in my pocket in smaller bills. The combined total was the max I would willingly spend.
6) I looked at it in person -- I had a list in my head of disqualifying traits: smells like cat pee, animal damage, bat/rat/mouse crap inside, urethane finish on it, rusty hinges, etc
It was/is in pretty good shape, certainly for the age, did not stink, had the expected level of dirt on it from being old and has an original varnish finish which I prefer.
I tried the bank envelope trick but the dude was hardcore and I had to pull money out of my pocket. I spent 75$ less than my top dollar, but more than I had hoped.
With something like this there is also the "out" of reselling if things go awry. I could recoup at least part of the money.
So far, no buyer's remorse. I really like it. It fit into the storage unit so no additional cost to keep it until I can put it into use.